Dr. John C. ShershowAdult ADHD PsychiatryCall (212) 265-4310
Menu

Key points

  • A 2018 network meta-analysis of 133 randomized trials found adult effect sizes versus placebo of -0.79 for amphetamines, -0.49 for methylphenidate and -0.45 for atomoxetine on clinician ratings at about 12 weeks.
  • A 2025 analysis of 113 trials and 14,887 adults found that only stimulants and atomoxetine reduced core symptoms on both self-ratings and clinician ratings.
  • A 2018 Cochrane review rated the evidence for CBT in adult ADHD as low quality while finding that CBT added to medication outperformed medication alone.
  • A Swedish study of 148,578 people found that starting ADHD medication was associated with lower all-cause mortality over two years (hazard ratio 0.79).
  • Another Swedish study linked each additional year of ADHD medication use with about 4% higher odds of cardiovascular disease, mainly hypertension and arterial disease.

Claims about ADHD treatment tend to come without numbers, or with numbers that have no source. This page reports what the largest studies in adults found, in figures, and is equally specific about what those studies cannot tell you. It contains no dosing information and no recommendation for any individual. Drug names appear because the studies report results by drug.

How to read the numbers

Trial results below are given as a standardized mean difference (SMD), a way of putting different rating scales on one ruler. A negative SMD means symptoms fell more than with placebo. By a common convention, about 0.2 is called a small effect, 0.5 medium and 0.8 large. An SMD describes the average across a group. It does not predict how one person will respond.

Safety studies below report odds ratios or hazard ratios. A value of 1.0 means no difference. Those studies are observational: researchers compared people who did and did not take medication in health registers, without assigning treatment at random.

Medication: what randomized trials show

Two large pooled analyses carry most of the weight.

Cortese and colleagues, Lancet Psychiatry, 2018. A network meta-analysis of 133 double-blind randomized trials, 51 of them in adults, with 8,131 adults in the efficacy analysis.

Ostinelli and colleagues, Lancet Psychiatry, 2025. A component network meta-analysis of 113 randomized trials and 14,887 adults covering drugs, psychological therapies and neurostimulation.

Treatment2018 analysis: clinician-rated SMD vs placebo2018 analysis: odds of stopping for side effects vs placebo
Amphetamines-0.793.26
Methylphenidate-0.492.39
Atomoxetine-0.452.33
Bupropion (not FDA-approved for ADHD)-0.46Not reported here
Modafinil (not FDA-approved for ADHD)Not better than placebo4.01

The 2018 authors concluded that amphetamines were the preferred first choice in adults for short-term treatment, weighing efficacy against tolerability. Every active drug in the table was also stopped for side effects more often than placebo.

The 2025 analysis reported stimulants as a group at -0.39 on self-ratings and -0.61 on clinician ratings, and atomoxetine at -0.38 and -0.51. Only stimulants and atomoxetine reduced core symptoms on both kinds of rating. Atomoxetine and guanfacine were less acceptable than placebo, meaning more people dropped out.

Two findings from the 2025 paper deserve attention because they cut against marketing claims:

  • Medication did not show a benefit on quality of life.
  • Evidence beyond the short term was thin.

Both analyses measured outcomes at about 12 weeks. Neither supports a statement about how well any treatment works over years.

CBT and other psychological treatment

A 2018 Cochrane review pooled 14 randomized trials with 700 adults. CBT plus medication did better than medication alone on clinician-rated symptoms (SMD -0.80, from two studies with 65 participants). CBT did better than a waiting list on self-reported symptoms (SMD -0.84, five studies). The reviewers rated this low-quality evidence that CBT may be beneficial in the short term.

The 2025 analysis found that CBT (-0.76), mindfulness (-0.79), psychoeducation (-0.77) and cognitive remediation (-1.35) reduced symptoms on clinician ratings. None did so on patients' own ratings, and results were inconsistent between raters.

The fair reading: CBT helps, the trials are small, and the evidence is strongest for CBT added to medication. The data do not show that it works as well as medication. The site's article on treating ADHD without medication covers the non-drug approaches.

Mortality: the 2024 JAMA study

Li and colleagues followed 148,578 people in Sweden aged 6 to 64 who were newly diagnosed with ADHD between 2007 and 2018. About 57% started medication within three months. Over two years:

  • All-cause mortality was 39.1 per 10,000 among those who started medication and 48.1 per 10,000 among those who did not (hazard ratio 0.79).
  • Deaths from unnatural causes such as accidents, poisoning and suicide were lower (25.9 versus 33.3 per 10,000, hazard ratio 0.75).
  • Deaths from natural causes did not differ significantly.

The median age at diagnosis was 17.4, so much of the group was young. The design was observational. Starting medication was associated with lower mortality. The study does not establish that medication prevents death.

Cardiovascular risk: the 2024 JAMA Psychiatry study

Zhang and colleagues used Swedish registers covering 278,027 people aged 6 to 64 with ADHD, comparing 10,388 who developed cardiovascular disease with 51,672 matched controls over a median 4.1 years.

  • Compared with no use, the odds of cardiovascular disease were 0.99 for up to one year of cumulative use, 1.09 for one to two years, 1.15 for two to three years, 1.27 for three to five years and 1.23 beyond five years.
  • Each additional year was linked to about 4% higher odds, concentrated in the first three years.
  • The increase was driven by hypertension and arterial disease.

This is an association in a case-control study. It does not show that medication causes heart disease, and it does not show that medication is free of cardiovascular risk. Its practical message matches stimulant labeling, which tells prescribers to monitor blood pressure and pulse. More detail is in ADHD medication, heart health and blood pressure.

Psychosis and mania: the 2024 hospital study

Moran and colleagues studied patients aged 16 to 35 hospitalized at McLean Hospital between 2005 and 2019: 1,374 with a first episode of psychosis or mania and 2,748 admitted for other psychiatric reasons. Past-month use of a prescription amphetamine was associated with higher odds of psychosis or mania (adjusted odds ratio 2.68). The odds were highest at the top dose level studied. Methylphenidate showed no association (0.91).

The participants were young psychiatric inpatients, and the comparison group was also hospitalized. The study gives no absolute risk for a typical adult outpatient. Stimulant labels direct prescribers to screen for risk factors for mania before starting treatment. See ADHD or bipolar disorder?

What observational studies can and cannot show

People who start medication differ from people who do not: in severity, in other diagnoses, in access to care, in how closely they are followed. Statistical adjustment narrows those differences and never removes them. This is called confounding, and it applies to the reassuring mortality finding as much as to the cautionary cardiovascular one.

What the evidence does not cover: effectiveness beyond about 12 weeks from the pooled trials, quality-of-life benefits from medication, and risk estimates for adults over 64, who were outside both Swedish studies.

What this means for a treatment decision

Group averages inform a decision and do not make it. Response, side effects, other health conditions and personal priorities vary, which is why treatment is adjusted at follow-up. The practice's treatment page describes how medication management works, and the Treatment and Medication hub collects related articles.

The next step in this guide is a side-by-side look at the options: ADHD medications approved for adults in 2026.

Questions

What percentage of adults improve with ADHD treatment?

The major pooled analyses report average symptom change, not a percentage of people who improve, so a single reliable percentage is not available from them. Figures such as "80 to 90 percent improve" circulate online without a traceable source.

Which works better in adults, stimulants or non-stimulants?

In the 2018 network meta-analysis, amphetamines had the largest average effect on clinician ratings, followed by methylphenidate and atomoxetine at similar levels. Averages do not determine the right choice for an individual, which depends on medical history, side effects and preference.

Does CBT work for adult ADHD?

Trials suggest it helps, especially when added to medication. A Cochrane review rated that evidence low quality because the trials were few and small, and a 2025 analysis found benefits on clinician ratings but not on patients' own ratings.

Is it safe to take ADHD medication long term?

The trials are too short to answer directly. A large observational study linked longer use with modestly higher odds of high blood pressure and arterial disease, and another linked starting medication with lower mortality over two years. Regular blood pressure and pulse checks are the standard precaution.

Do ADHD medications cause psychosis?

One 2024 study of hospitalized patients aged 16 to 35 found higher odds of first-episode psychosis or mania with recent prescription amphetamine use, highest at the top dose level, and no association with methylphenidate. It does not give a risk figure for typical outpatients. Anyone experiencing a psychiatric emergency can call or text 988.

Sources

  1. Cortese et al., Lancet Psychiatry: Comparative efficacy and tolerability of medications for ADHD in children, adolescents, and adults, network meta-analysis (September 2018)
  2. Ostinelli et al., Lancet Psychiatry: Comparative efficacy and acceptability of pharmacological, psychological, and neurostimulatory interventions for ADHD in adults (January 2025)
  3. Lopez et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews: Cognitive-behavioural interventions for ADHD in adults (March 2018)
  4. Li et al., JAMA: ADHD pharmacotherapy and mortality in individuals with ADHD (March 12, 2024)
  5. Zhang et al., JAMA Psychiatry: ADHD medications and long-term risk of cardiovascular diseases (February 2024)
  6. Moran et al., American Journal of Psychiatry: Risk of incident psychosis and mania with prescription amphetamines (October 2024)
  7. DailyMed (National Library of Medicine): Adderall XR prescribing information, label effective April 30, 2026
  8. American Family Physician: Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder in Adults (August 2024)

Ready to talk about an evaluation?

Call the office to ask about availability and to schedule your first appointment. Hours are by appointment only.